Sinclair Lewis and the book ‘It Can’t Happen Here’

Clearly political in its motivation and at minimum cautionary in its tone, the 1935 Sinclair Lewis novel It Can’t Happen Here was written as a warning against the possibility that fascism could rise in the United States of America. Set against the backdrop of notable European examples from the period in Germany and Italy, with many in the North American citizenry of the time oblivious to it, the work was timely then and arguably is again at the time of this review.

(Pictured here is Sinclair Lewis, writer of the political novel It Can’t Happen Here).

Concisely stated in this quotation from the Encyclopedia Britannica, the novel occurs “[d]uring the presidential election of 1936, [when] Doremus Jessup, a newspaper editor, observes with dismay that many of the people he knows support the candidacy of a fascist, Berzelius Windrip. When Windrip wins the election, he forcibly gains control of Congress and the Supreme Court and, with the aid of his personal paramilitary storm troopers, turns the United States into a totalitarian state. Jessup opposes him, is captured, and escapes to Canada.”

(Book covers for the Sinclair Lewis novel It Can’t Happen Here, which was first published in 1935).

The book It Can’t Happen Here bends towards a dystopian pessimism that highlights the baser instincts inherent in the fascist model of governing. The disdain for popular elections while subordinating individual will to the collective good are examined alongside abuses to human rights that grow more extreme as the novel continues. The dark subject matter builds while effectively offering the cautionary tale, or alarm, that the book intended.

(Sinclair Lewis, pictured here, won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1930).

Overall, the tone of the book coupled with the fact that it is election season at home worked for me at this time. I give It Can’t Happen Here by Sinclair Lewis 4.0-stars on a scale of one-to-five.

Matt – Wednesday, November 1, 2023

Margaret Atwood and the book ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’

Canadian writer, literary critic, teacher, environmental activist and inventor Margaret Atwood wrote the book The Handmaid’s Tale, originally published in hardback in 1985. “The book, set in New England in the near future, posits a Christian fundamentalist theocratic regime in the former United States that arose as a response to a fertility crisis,” as quoted from the Encyclopædia Britannica.

(Alternate covers for the Margaret Atwood book The Handmaid’s Tale).

Offred, the primary protagonist responding to the world around her, narrates The Handmaid’s Tale in a manner that alternates between her present life and memories of her past. The memories frequently include added commentary and explanation that offers context and depth to what she discerns and how she, Offred, makes sense of the world that she inhabits. The world is one where a military coup killed the president and most members of the United States congress, leaving a country that became the Republic of Gilead.

(Margaret Atwood wrote The Handmaid’s Tale, which was first published in 1985).

The book picks up from a point shortly after this change to a dystopian republic, with the freedoms, decision-making and autonomy of women systematically curtailed in cruel and demeaning ways. The novel works to humanize how this would feel, and the ghastly and corrupting damage to women and society that experiencing this firsthand can have, should the worldview come to pass.

(Margaret Atwood, the writer of The Handmaid’s Tale, was born in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada).

In addition to severely curtailing women’s freedoms in the name of male control, the novel also addresses assigning women to various classes. The classes included “childless Wives of the Commanders; the housekeeping Marthas; and the reproductive Handmaids, who turn their offspring over to the Wives and are called by the names of their assigned Commanders. Ranked under the Commanders are Guardians, who have police powers, and the society is permeated with government spies called Eyes. Those who cannot conform are sent to the Colonies,” as correctly mentioned by this Encyclopedia Brittanica reference. Further, African Americans (presumably as children of Noah‘s son Ham from the Bible), were additionally resettled.

(Other notable books written by Margaret Atwood include Surfacing, Cat’s Eye, Alias Grace, The Blind Assassin, Oryx and Crake and The Testaments).

The depth of the story that follows the framework above addressed tortuous household conditions regarding reproduction, life with Offred’s commander, Fred, grocery shopping with Ofglen, a handmaid to a separate commander, sightings of executed prisoners left hung in public, beastly reproductive rituals, and an odd interpersonal attempt to connect between Fred and Offred that adds depth to the narrative value for how stilted and repressive life really becomes in this world based in the not-to-distant future.

(Margaret Atwood wrote The Handmaid’s Tale. The Testaments, first published in 2019, is Atwood‘s sequel to The Handmaid’s Tale).

The premise of The Handmaid’s Tale is interesting. The narrative being primarily firsthand aids the engagement of the tale, with the message a timely one given political realities of the United States currently. That the narrative of this book expresses a fear for what lies behind much of what fuels the underlying disagreements about the decision-making in play is presented in an understandable and forthright manner. I rate The Handmaid’s Tale as written by Margaret Atwood at 4.25-stars on a scale of 1-to-5.

Matt – Monday, May 23, 2022

Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing by Robert Caro

Robert Caro won numerous book awards for his extensive biographies of the lives and power politics of New York city public official Robert Moses and Texas politician/United States president Lyndon Johnson.

RC Working 2(Robert Caro wrote Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing in addition to books that won the Pulitzer Prize).

Included in those awards were the Pulitzer Prizes for The Power Broker: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York and Master Of The Senate: The Years of Lyndon Johnson. During the writing of his four of five planned volumes on Lyndon Johnson, Caro took the time to write the book that is the subject of this examination, namely the memoir Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing.

RC Working 3(Robert Caro is known for covering the acquisition and exercise of power through reviews of public figures Robert Moses and Lyndon Johnson).

The interest that Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing had for me is to understand the process, means, and meaning that Robert Caro experienced in the way that he went about his researching and writing process. For this interest I was rewarded quite well in getting those things as well as a cursory glimpse into what the process was like for Caro and his wife, authority on medieval and modern French history Ina Caro. Ina Caro proved to be an immense if understated support system for Robert Caro, the man, during what were some lean years for the couple.

RC Working 4(Robert Caro won the Pulitzer Prize for his books The Power Broker: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York and Master Of The Senate: The Years of Lyndon Johnson).

The book Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing offers much value in terms of feeling the first person experience of interviewing public figures, running into roadblocks along the way, and filling in gaps through exhaustive research to the point of compelling folks who would otherwise stonewall access to allow for some form of access. Even with compelling research, sensitive findings and the outcomes these brought from Robert Moses or the family of Lyndon Johnson proved interesting.

RC Working 5(Robert Caro as a younger man).

As stated earlier, my desire for reading Working: Researching, Interviewing, Writing was to understand the process, means, and meaning that Robert Caro experienced. I was not disappointed, which leads me to my rating of 3.75-stars on a scale of one-to-five for the book.

Matt – Saturday, September 07, 2019

 

Erik Larson and ‘The Devil in the White City’

Erik Larson offered us an intertwined narrative of the Chicago’s World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893, the architect of the exposition Daniel Hudson Burnham, and the infamy of a contemporaneous serial killer Herman Webster Mudgett (aka Dr. Henry Howard Holmes) in his 2003 book The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America.

devil white city 2 - erik larson(Erik Larson, author of The Devil in the White City).

The two biggest stories of The Devil in the White City included were the fact of the world’s fair in Chicago, Illinois as well as the contemporaneous operation of a serial killer in the same region. The era of the exposition story began following the American Civil War, in the aftermath of Reconstruction Era yet before the before the economic Panic of 1893 began to capture its legs.

devil white city 3 - daniel hudson burnham(Daniel Hudson Burnham).

The awarding of the 1893 was decided largely by the United States Congress around 1891. Other cities in the running for the Columbian Exposition included New York City, Washington, D.C., and St. Louis. After a series of votes by Congress that ultimately witnessed the serious contention being between Chicago and New York City, the Midwestern city won the prize. Daniel Hudson Burnham ultimately was named the chief architect for the exposition.

devil white city 4 - dr. henry howard holmes (herbert webster mudgett)(Herman Webster Mudgett (aka Dr. Henry Howard Holmes)).

Before getting too far into that story and the telling of how Burnham became the architect, we did learn about his schooling and his architectural business partner, John Wellborn Root. We also learned of the background of one Herman Webster Mudgett, a confidence man who we first learn could not pass pharmacy school. Mudgett, who we later learn is skilled at forming fictitious individuals, supporting documentation, and the gaining of trust from bankers, employees, and ladies in Chicago, both established and new to the city. One of Mudgett‘s prominent aliases was as Dr. Henry Howard Holmes.

devil white city 5 - chicago's world's columbian exposition of 1893(Chicago’s World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893).

The larger story introduced us through Burnham and Mudgett was the planning and growth of the notion of city from a largely agrarian background. Both shared a certain degree of ambition pointed in different directions. Burnham wanted to grow something that surpassed The Paris Exposition Universelle of 1889). The Paris Exposition drew magnificent crowds and demonstrated the new fangled Eiffel Tower, which stands today. The Chicago Expostion’s answer to this was the first ever Ferris Wheel.

devil white city 6 - ferris wheel(The Ferris Wheel).

George W. Ferris invented the Ferris Wheel, which took the principle of two concentric circles with a load of passenger-carrying vehicles between them to new heights. Placed on the midway of the fair, the notion of a midway with a Ferris Wheel (or Eiffel Tower) at one extreme became the standard of Amusement Parks, Theme Parks, and carnivals that would follow in the next century. The father of Roy Disney and Walt Disney, Elias Disney, helped build Chicago’s Columbian Exposition.

devil white city 7 - ferris wheel(The Ferris Wheel).

While much of the effort of building the grounds of the exposition were experiencing their starts, stops, and complications, we witnessed Herman Webster Mudgett use less than ethical means to acquire a pharmacy from a widow. We saw the explanation of her disappearance fabricated by Mudgett. Other ladies and children would disappear at the hands of Mudgett, with little in the way of suspicion being cast his way in terms of suspicion until such time as the life insurance companies pressed their cases. Herman Webster Mudgett used his falsely made wealth to build a death house that led multiple murders at his, Mudgett‘s, hands.

devil white city 8 - the palace of fine arts - now the museum of science and industry(The Palace of Fine Arts – now The Museum of Science and Industry).

The official opening of the Columbian Exposition occurred in the fall of 1892, to coincide with the actual date of Christopher Columbus‘ arrival in the new world. The actual event ran from May through October of 1893. The exposition included many temporary built in an ornate Neoclassical style and painted white. It was the white painting at the fair site that led to the Exposition being called the White City.

devil white city 9 - the grand basin(The Grand Basin).

L. Frank Baum, writer of The Wizard of Oz book, was said to have been inspired by the grandeur of Chicago Exposition when creating his series of books. The use of Westinghouse alternating current incandescent light bulbs was proven at the fair. Shredded Wheat as a product was introduced at the fair.

devil white city 10 - the court of honor(The Court of Honor).

Herman Webster Mudgett would be caught and found guilty of some of his crimes after having taken at least two of his victims to the Columbian Exposition. Daniel Hudson Burnham helped plan the cities of Cleveland, San Francisco, and Manilla before having influence upon the ribbon of lakefront parks and the Magnificent Mile of Michigan Avenue within Chicago. Burnham Park became a thing after the exposition, in part to honor the architect. Modern day Solider Field and the Field Museum are located within that park. The Palace of Fine Arts became the modern day Museum of Science and Industry.

The narrative style of The Devil in White City made for the telling of non-fiction in a means familiar to fiction readers. The stories were compelling, if not falling into the macabre when discussing the Murder Castle of Herman Webster Mudgett and such. Erik Larson depicted two of Mudgett‘s murders following research at libraries. I enjoyed the experience and would recommend it to those interested both in true crime as well as tales of the Chicago Exposition. My grade is 4.0-stars on a scale of 1-to-5 stars.

Matt – Saturday, January 19, 2019